Vicar Eugene Willie ~ June 23, 1956 - May 15, 1958
Rev. Jack Luz ~ April 22, 1958 - November 6, 1960
Rev. James Roseman ~ July 2, 1961 - May 26, 1968
Rev. Frank Winter ~ August 18, 1968 - December 28, 1969
Rev. William Seiberg ~ June 28, 1970 - September 13, 1972
Rev. William Barthel ~ October 22, 1972 - May 8, 1977
Rev. Charles Smith ~ June 12, 1977 - March 16, 1980
Rev. Richard Hill ~ October 19, 1980 - February 8, 1986
Rev. Michael Bingenheimer ~ July 20, 1986 - August 30, 1994
Rev. David Meyer ~ August 20, 1995 - September 24, 2000
Rev. Jim Daub ~ February 3, 2002 - Present